liesI’ve been hearing a lot lately about what honesty really is and if  it is socially acceptable to tell white lies.  We all know the golden rule of honesty being the best policy, but I don’t really believe that.

If your friend goes out and gets a new hairstyle, and you really hate it, do you say “Oh my god, what the hell have you done to your head?  It’s a good thing hair grows back”!  No, most people will not be blunt like that.  We tell those famous little white lies so we don’t hurt people’s feelings.  I think pretty much all of us do this.  I would want people to do that for me.

The other issue I have been hearing regarding honesty is lying by omission.  Apparently, this is bad.  I hear it’s like outright lying.  I guess I have a bit of a looser moral code than the so-called experts, because I use this tactic all the time.  Call it what you will, but I have no ethical dilemma not telling someone something.

I generally use omission in two situations.  One, like little white lies.  For example, your friend gets a new dress or pair of shoes that you think are hideous.  You don’t want to compliment your friend on the purchase, because this will only encourage her to wear the ugly thing again, so you pretend you don’t notice anything  new.

I’ll let you in on a little secret I have.  If I know the person will expect me to notice they have something new, I will say “Oh, you have new shoes”.  The person has noted that you made an observation about them and they think it is a compliment.  In reality, I said no such thing.  Very misleading, but not a bald-faced lie.

The other situation in which I use omission is when I think someone is prying and I am not ready to tell this person certain information about myself.  Being in a profession where strict personal boundaries are a necessity, I don’t see how this can be considered lying.  Not everyone needs to know everything about me.  I call it professionalism.

The last thing that I’ve been hearing about honesty that bothers me is exaggeration.  I exaggerate ALL THE TIME.  See?  I really do.  I don’t do it on purpose (most of the time).  I’m an excitable, boisterous person and when I talk, tell a story or blog, there will be some exaggeration.  After all, I want people to be interested, don’t I?

So, what do you think?  Am I a terribly immoral person because I do not tell the complete truth all the time?  I’m a big, fat liar.  Yep, that’s right.  I lie.  DO you?


4 Responsed To This Post

Subscribes to this post comment rss or trackback url
mygif_alt
N.P. said, June 10th, 2009 at 4:34 pm

yeah, I do – every day, some way, some how – mostly by doing that “lying by omission” thing but, yeah, I lie – seriously, though, in this big crazy world of ours, who doesn’t lie? in certain situations, it’s dangerous NOT to – lying is one of the last survival instincts that human beings still possess and in this big crazy world that we live in, that instinct kicking in (or not) can make a big difference in one’s quality of life – do you know what I mean?
you show me someone who tells the truth every day, every time, to every person and if they actually exist (which I doubt), I will show you someone with no friends, no job, an angry family and who has probably been punched in the face at least once or twice because, I gotta tell ya, honesty is NOT always the best policy – in spite of what they might say, people really DON’T want to hear the truth all the time and one is foolish if they knowingly ignore the signals that might be telling you that a specific situation is one of those times but yet still choose to “poke the bear” and be totally honest with someone….
I’m not saying that everything that comes out of your mouth should be a lie – for the most part, people should be able to believe most of what you say – but sometimes, it’s just like we were taught as children – that “if you can’t say something nice, don’t say anything at all” – kinda pee’s me off that somehow that concept has been twisted into meaning you are lying but, whatever – unless it’s to cover up something that’s blatantly illegal or dangerous or just plain mean, I am willing to do whatever it takes to keep peace in my little part of the world and to keep my ass from getting kicked more than it absolutely needs to be…..
so, yeah, I lie – I’m a big fat liar – but do you know what? so is everyone else I know so most days, I’m in damned good company……

mygif
Hilary said, June 12th, 2009 at 1:48 pm

I will never forget what a metropolitan police officer said, she said “honesty is subjective, integrity is not”. So subjectively, if you withheld information it is not lying. If you did tell information that was wilfully prevaricating and misleading, that is lying.

Nitpicking about ‘white lies’ is just obfuscation. How would you feel if you had a boss and they lied about your wages?

What if that same boss said, I cannot give you an increase because we are suffering in these economic times? Is he or she lying?

mygif_alt
Finola Prescott said, June 15th, 2009 at 8:22 am

Hey, I think I can honestly say, without exaggeration or withholding anything that I think you’re, well….NORMAL!

Of course this thing about opinion on things being a relative of lying is something that gets me – I may hate your shoes, you may love them, just our opinions and tastes, and no, I’m not into unnecessary insulting or uttering of hurtful things, so better not to say anything, I agree.

Now if they’re 7″ heels that look like they’re about to snap off, I’d be lying if I said, “Wow, those must be so comfortable, wish I had a pair!”

Enjoyed reading your blog – so far, sure I’ll be back (no lie:)

mygif
Kim said, June 15th, 2009 at 7:01 pm

Most people confuse honesty for a blunt instrument. They use it like a baseball bat to ‘tell the truth’ to others. That isn’t honesty, it’s brutality, and worse than lying.

Honesty and tact need to go hand in hand. This means there may be times when you are neutral- like with the shoes. You say something that is neither a yes or no, just an acknowledgment.

However, it would be wrong to not speak up when something really matters to you. When you need to express something, have it heard, and hopefully had it responded well to. That is when tact is most important.

Lastly, we are human and we lie. I know I have and will in the future. We all lie for the same reasons, to protect ourselves, to protect others, because we are afraid, or because we don’t care. What isn’t healthy is if it negates and hides our own truths which we could be sharing with those we care about.

Response To This Topic

Please Note: The comment moderation maybe active so there is no need to resubmit your comment

Bad Behavior has blocked 13 access attempts in the last 7 days.